Switzerland Sells Stake in UBS for a Profit

Posted by ZikVn On 12:36 AM


In this Sept. 17, 2008 file photo the lLogo of Swiss bank UBS is seen in Zurich, Switzerland. Swiss bank UBS AG said Tuesday, Feb. 10, 2009 it lost 8.1 billion Swiss francs (U.S. dlrs 7.57 billion) in the fourth quarter and announced it would cut a further 2,000 jobs as it refocuses on its home market after a troubled year abroad. The results exceeded the fears of analysts, who on average had predicted net losses of 6.2 billion francs (U.S. dlrs 5.79 bil



Walter Bieri/European Pressphoto Agency

A branch of UBS in Zurich. One analyst said Switzerland’s sale of the stake looked “pretty good.”

Published: August 20, 2009
PARIS — Switzerland became the first European economy to dispose of its holding in a distressed domestic bank on Thursday, selling its 9 percent stake in UBS at a profit of more than $1 billion only a day after agreeing to release information to the United States on clients suspected of evading taxes.

The Swiss government gave 6 Swiss billion francs, or $5.6 billion, to UBS in October to help shore up the bank in exchange for debt convertible into common stock. On Thursday, the government said it had sold its 332.2 million shares to institutional investors at 16.50 Swiss francs ($15.38) each. Including a payment of 1.8 billion francs ($1.68 billion) that the government is receiving from UBS, the proceeds total about 7.2 billion francs ($6.7 billion).

The Swiss government said Thursday that its net gain was equivalent to an annualized rate of return of about 32 percent.

“They are substantially in the money,” Guy de Blonay, a fund manager at Henderson New Star in London, said. “It looks pretty good.”

The sale puts other governments with troubled banks in the spotlight. At the height of the financial crisis, government interventions on both sides of the Atlantic helped to avoid a collapse of the credit system — especially after the failure of Lehman Brothers in September — as traditional financing dried up. Now that markets have started to recover, attention is turning to exit strategies.

In the United States, several financial firms — including American Express, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase and Morgan Stanley — have already bought back warrants from the Treasury Department, which the government received as part of its $700 billion bailout plan.

Some analysts said that several deals yielded a profit for taxpayers, with Goldman Sachs calculating a 23 percent annualized return for the government on its $1.1 billion warrant purchase. But analysts have said that other firms, like Morgan Stanley, paid less than the full value of their warrants.

A report by the Bank for International Settlements, released in July, found that the overall amount of resources committed to bank bailouts in 11 countries — including France, Germany, Japan, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Britain and the United States — was 5 trillion euros, or $7.1 trillion.

The bank, based in Basel, Switzerland, said interventions were most significant in countries like Britain — outlays reached 44.1 percent of gross domestic product there — and in the Netherlands. The British government has said that it does not want to be a long-term investor in its largest banks and expects to sell the stakes as soon as possible, with pressure to sell at a profit growing before a general election within the year.

“The U.K. government would love to get out and wave some pound notes at the voters,” Gordon Scott, a banking analyst at Fitch Ratings in London, said. “The markets have recovered a bit, but we’re not yet there for them to make a profit.”

Daniel Gros, director of the Center for European Policy Studies in Brussels, said there was no blanket model for divestment, and no fixed timetable.

In cases like UBS where governments supported investment banks, the governments should soon be able to exit profitably, Mr. Gros said. Those companies have been helped by stronger interbank lending and the rise in asset prices.

Other cases, where governments supported deposit-taking institutions like Northern Rock and Royal Bank of Scotland in Britain, Fortis in the Netherlands and Commerzbank in Germany, are more complex.

“The problems at these banks tend to be slower to come to the surface and show up on the balance sheet,” Mr. Gros said. “It may take years to have an idea of how large the losses are.”

The report by the Bank for International Settlements said governments should start preparing an exit strategy “right now,” but that those plans should be put in play only when there was a “virtuous circle” for banks of “mutually reinforcing increase in capital and borrowing, on the one hand, and lending and profits on the other.”

Britain, for example, took a 43 percent stake in the Lloyds Banking Group last year and owns 70 percent of the Royal bank of Scotland, whose shares rose this month — meaning the government would book a profit by selling now.

But British Financial Investments, which manages the holdings for the government, has said that it may take years to sell the stake.

The Swiss government had said on several occasions that it wanted to sell its UBS stake as soon as justifiable, but that UBS had to be on solid ground first. The government and regulators now judge that to be the case after its deal with the United States government and after a capital increase in June that lifted the bank’s Tier 1 capital ratio, a measure of financial strength, to 13.2 percent, from 10.5 percent at the end of March.

“People were afraid that the government would hold the stake and try to influence the business strategy,” said Mathias Büeler at Kepler Capital Markets in Zurich. “That concern is now resolved.”

The sale of the Swiss stake, Mr. Büeler added, also calmed investors’ concerns that UBS would become uncompetitive with American banks.

France participated in a cross-border bailout of Dexia and injected funds into large domestic lenders. A French official, granted anonymity because he was not authorized to speak publicly, said there were advantages to waiting. The French government, he said, is earning interest on its assets and would like to retain leverage to make sure credit is flowing. The finance ministry would like to see durable signs of a recovery before considering an exit, he said.

In Germany, the government hinted Thursday that it was too early to discuss selling its stakes. The government is reorganizing Hypo Real Estate, a major mortgage lender. Chancellor Angela Merkel said in February that the bailout of Hypo must be “as justifiable and cheap as possible for taxpayers.”

The Netherlands does not foresee disposing of its core holdings until at least 2011. First, it needs assurance that the banks’ stability is guaranteed, that they can stand alone in a competitive market and earn back the taxpayer’s investment, said Lies Weitenberg, spokeswoman for the Dutch finance ministry.

Matthew Saltmarsh reported from Paris and Julia Werdigier from London. Michael J. de la Merced contributed from New York.

0 Response to "Switzerland Sells Stake in UBS for a Profit"

Post a Comment

    Sign in


    Visitor Maps